Thursday, April 1, 2010

Whoops.

I realized that in my post from last night I completely misquoted the poem, which really made my point moot. No more 2am blog posts. I swear. Anyway, here's a new one to make up for it.


In class today, Professor Porter pointed out that we should be reminded of Wordsworth when listening to the flow, cadence, and diction of "Goblin Market." I hadn't really made an in depth connection between Rossetti and Wordsworth other than the fact that Rossetti probably did read him and was influenced in some way. But going back and looking at it from that perspective, I now see a much closer resemblance. Both poets, when creating the settings of their poems, use imagery that could almost be described as pastoral -- Wordsworth with his fields and flowers; Rossetti with her fruits and markets. However, both do so in such a way that the pastoral sense that might normally accompany these images is distorted. The flower in Wordsworth may mark a grave, as Rossetti's fruits are associated with rape, loss of innocence, improper desire, and so forth. This distortion, coupled with the almost sing-songy nature that both poets employ, creates an interesting dynamic that completely perverts all sense of what's what by the end of the poem. Obviously the outcomes are somewhat different in regards to physical life, but the structure and setup are very similar, and each done very well in their own regards.

Ekphrasis in/on the Blessed Damozel


Take a look at Rossetti's painting; if you click on the image, you'll get a larger view, and you can see the poem inscribed on the bottom of the frame. As we discussed with Browning and Tennyson, ekphrasis is the technical term for a work of art that imitates or represents another work of art in a different medium, usually the verbal representation of visual representation. In this case, the direction of representation is reversed, and raises questions about how the painting asks us to interpret the poem. Does it offer a particular interpretation? Tell us how to read the poem? In its material presentation, this work creates the image as the true text, and the poem serves as a kind of footnote that explains the image: is Rossetti suggesting that the poem works in the service of something other than itself? How then does thiis suggest we understand his illustrations to his sister's poem "Goblin Market"?

Wednesday, March 31, 2010

Rossetti's "Goblin Market"


Well, I hope that I have not been overly influenced by my seminar class on the art of love (which stresses all things Freudian and strange and for which this poem is also due on Thursday April 1), but I noticed some weird love relationships in this poem. First, there is the strange and inordinate desire to taste the fruit of the goblin men, even though Laura and Lizzie know they shouldn’t. Laura, however, cannot resist and succumbs to their seduction, becoming a slave to her desire. She begins to wither and die because she cannot get any more fruit, she cannot even hear or see the goblin men. This part—to me—suggests a sexual metaphor. She has given herself to the goblin men and satisfied both of their desires—to “come buy” and to eat. Since she has given away part of herself; as Lizzie puts it when referring to Jeanie: “Who should have been a bride; / But who for joys brides hope to have / Fell sick and died” (ll. 313-315). The “joys brides hope to have” seems to refer to the sexual relationship of the wedding night. Second, there is the bizarre relationship between Lizzie and Laura. They are sisters, but share one bed and sleep “Cheek to cheek and breast to breast / Locked together in one nest” (ll. 197-198). Also, Lizzie’s language after she goes to get fruit to satisfy Laura’s desires is very erotic: “Hug me, kiss me, suck my juices / Squeezed from goblin fruits for you, / Goblin pulp and goblin dew. / Eat me, drink me, love me; / Laura, make much of me” (ll. 468-472). Laura’s response to Lizzie’s invitation is the following: “She clung about her sister, / Kissed and kissed and kissed her… / She kissed and kissed her with a hungry mouth” (ll. 485-486, 492). This seems abnormal, exorbitant, just a little strange. As we see in the picture that precedes the poem, the sisters are locked in a loving embrace. It is the natural pose for two lovers sleeping together rather than two sisters. Also, it seems that Laura is dreaming of the goblin men and their fruits as she sleeps. These two representations of “love” are both strange, especially since the poem ends on the slightly didactic note of “For there is no friend like a sister” even though both sisters have married and had children (l. 562). Overall, I had to ask, ‘What is this poem trying to get at?’ There is the warning against giving oneself to men and the message to trust in sisters, but both sisters do marry men and have children. Any thoughts?

Sisters in the Goblin Market

This poem is particularly interesting in that it has more of a narrative feel to it than most other poems. Through the comparison of two sisters, we find out what happens to women when they go astray. Lizzie is the more cautious of the two sisters, telling Laura that "Twilight is not good for maidens," and accepting fruit from strange men is dangerous and unacceptable. These goblins don't even appear to have human-like faces. Rosetti describes them as
"One had a rat's face, / One whisked a tail, /One tramped at a rat's pace, / One crawled like a snail / One like a wombat prowled obtuse and furry, / One like a ratel tumbled hurry scurry..."
Here is an image I found of the "goblins" which look more like animals than actual goblins.
This link is more what I had in mind of what goblins look like. http://enthusiasm.cozy.org/wp-content/uploads/2008/01/goblinmarket.png

However, all of these talking creatures reminds me of Alice and Wonderland...considering next week we will be reading that story, perhaps this is a kind of 'pre' Wonderland?

Like Alice, she enters a world she is unfamiliar with, and she falls head over heels into this dreamlike trance caused by the fruit and the misleading "dove-like" voices of the goblins.
In the end, it is Laura's sister who saves her. Lizzie is the rational, grounded sister, and she does not react to the goblin's violent attacks on her. However, for how hard Lizzie works to ignore the goblins, I found this particular quote interesting, when she heads off to buy the fruit for her sister's sake:

"At twilight halted by the brook:
And for the first time in her life
Began to listen and look."

She loosens her morals for the sake of her sister, she does not ignore the symbols of sexual desire (which are represented by the abundance of fruit), but she does not give in all the way as Laura does. She does not figuratively "give herself up" to the goblins by cutting her hair, and they react violently. However, her courage pays off and Laura is saved, except I am a little fuzzy on what exactly it is that saves her...if that could be clarified that would be great.

Overall, I think this poem is a good midway point from the Fairy Tale "Romance Perverted" poems that we studied last week and Alice and Wonderland for next week.

Caliban Upon Setebos

Since no one decided to contemplate, in my opinion, the weirdest poem we have read so far, I decided to post on "Caliban on Setebos," having previously studied it with Professor Porter and attempted to write a paper on it. The poem is a contemplation of Natural Selection, and Caliban misunderstands this process because he is unwilling to accept that his low societal standing is natural. He projects his bitterness and anger onto Setebos, or Natural Selection, and twists its role in nature. In order for Setebos to be an agent of Natural Selection, his behavior must embody the scientific tenet of Charles Darwin’s "On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection". Darwin asserts “any variation, however slight...if it be in any degree profitable to an individual...in its infinitely complex relation to other organic beings and to external nature, will tend to the preservation of that individual” (Darwin 132-33). He also notes that competition develops from the “struggle for existence that inevitably follows from the high rate at which all organic beings tend to increase” (134). Caliban notes this variation of individuals when he speculates upon and imitates the behavior of Setebos with a population of crabs. Each crab has a unique physical variation that is then associated with its success in life: “the first straggler that boasts purple spots / shall join the file, one pincer twisted off; / ‘say, this bruised fellow shall receive a worm, / and two worms he whose nippers end in red” (Browning 104-07). Caliban recognizes that physical traits determine the crab's success, but he believes their fate depends on his whims he explains, “as it likes me each time, I do: so He” (108). The grammatical structure of Caliban’s statement, with Caliban’s behavior preceding Setebos’, indicates that Caliban is projecting his emotions and logic onto Setebos. This discards Darwin’s concept of random variation for the idea of random success in life, twisting Caliban’s perception of the rudimentary tenet of Natural Selection. I wont point out Caliban's confusion throughout the rest of the poem, but for Setebos fulfills the remaining tenants of Natural Selection through several other organisms. The squirrel and the urchin embody Survival of the Fittest while the "icy fish" occupies an environmental niche. Browning's poem is an elaborate portrayal of Natural Selection and the problem it poses to disenfranchised members of society.

Rosetti The Blessed Damozel

As I was reading Rosetti's The Blessed Damozel, I understood how powerful his language and description were throughout the poem. He manages to use words to create vivid pictures, almost cinemagraphic in a way that are very similar to Milton's descriptions in Paradise Lost. This picturesque quality to his poetry helps narrate the story a lot better because it helps create a myriad of images that reflect the story he is telling. It also exemplifies the efforts poets like Rosetti put forth to interweave the spiritual traditions, the pastoral, along with a mystic one that reads more like a fairytale story. The poem begins with a great picturesque description of Heaven and unravels from there to describe the desire of the Blessed Damozel to eventually meet the man she loves in the Heavenly kingdom. I also noticed how important it was for poets during this era like Rosetti to marry poetry to the arts, as a way to strengthen, prove, and display the power of words. Like Browning, Rosetti is trying to incorporate many elements in his poetry in order to legitimize poetry and the power it holds.

The sanctity of nature in "Forsaken Garden"

The author of "A Forsaken Garden" had a lifelong disdain for the crown of England as well as the church. These feelings as well as his alcoholism probably held back Swineburn from a term as Poet Laureate. Because of this I would suggest a reading of this poem as a piece that rejects the manmade institutions of the world. I believe the poem argues that all things associated with humanity, even death and love, are temporary. Swineburn also had a great love of the sea that he cultivated as a youth and this poem is very representative of that mariner's spirit and the feeling that the natural world and the sea in particular will outlive and outlast all things.

Form Understood as Content

We talked a lot about the content of "My Last Duchess" in class, in terms of both the objectification of the Duchess, the power paranoia of the Duke and the relationship to audience. The content of this poem, however, is also specifically enacted in its form in the phrase unit and meter, the defamiliariazaiton of the objects of the poem, the framing, and the imposition of structure from the Duke. The poem is tightly knit to convey the same structurally and formally precisely what it shows through content. The strict iambic pentameter and heroic couplets lends itself to the almost maniacal control exercised by the Count. By speaking of both painting and Duchess in unfamiliar tones, Browning creates a transfer of the usual perception of an object into the sphere of new perception with roughened, impeded language. Even the poem itself is framed like the painting discussed, the Duke's talking directly to his audience surrounding his story of his wife. The structure is ultimately directly the imposition of the Duke, although the structure also points to the difficulty that the Duke has in asserting this control. The enjambments of the poem, for example, occur when he speaks of his wife and her death, imparting a feeling of loss of control as he struggles to reassert himself against her memory and the power of authorship of the painting. By creating this double layer of content, with form as content and content as content, Browning posits art (in this case the poem) as a way of breaking down our easy or "natural" way of perception to induce a new way of seeing.

Tuesday, March 30, 2010

Women Trapped Cont.

I thought that today's readings were a good follow-up to Nathaniel's post from last week for several reasons. In particular, the idea of the arrogance of men really caught my attention in Browning's "Porphyria's Lover." When I read it, I really noticed the enormous lack of empathy from the narrator. His total disengagement and lack of humanity was so petrifying, and this tone might reflect some commentary on men in society. His attitude toward Porphyria lacks any sense of chivalry, compassion or emotion. Indeed, at the end of the poem, the narrator is even arrogant toward God in his snide remark that "God has not said a word." It seems that these romantic poems portray hyper-dependent women and utterly senseless men. That's a bad combination.

Monday, March 29, 2010

Clarity in Properiza Rossi

As I was researching Felicia Heman's life, I found it particularly interesting that her work was often assigned to schoolchildren. Her poem celebrates moments clarity and optimism, which would indeed be a valuable message for children to hear. Lines like
"The bright work grows beneath my hands, unfolding as a rose leaf after leaf, to beauty, line by line",

celebrate poetic talent and could be read as encouragment to succeed in spite of life's obstacles, which are, in the case of this poem, related to love. Unlike the gothics and romantics, Heman seems to rejoice in her poetic felecity and its ability to convey the pangs and joys of being in love. There is a great sense of agency and purposefullness in this poem that Wordsworth, Keats and Colerige lacked.

Properzia Rossi - Killed into Art

Last semester in one of my classes we read a feminist critique of Snow White about women who had been "killed into art" - basically meaning that the aesthetic ideal of the woman had made them into nothing but objects, and their existence as three-dimensional, complicated people was basically negated by the patriarchal ideal.

I think that works really well here with Properzia Rossi - first of all, the whole reason she cares so much about the statue she's making is not for any personal pleasure, but because the one person she loves doesn't love her because she's not beautiful enough for him. As a result, she has to make a statue that he might appreciate for its beauty. That way, he'll love some part of her - the beauty of the statue which her talent has created. But more than a representation of her talent, I feel like the statue is the concrete image she always wanted to be...and that's what I feel is kind of wrong with her mentality here. That she doesn't do it for herself, that the only reason she wants to have fame is so that he might recognize her, however insubstantially, and think fondly of her in the future.

Then again - why does anyone try to achieve fame? And the problem with feminist critiques in my mind is why does anyone do anything? Being in love with someone seems to me to be a pretty legitimate reason to make a statue, at least as legitimate as trying to get fame forever. I guess we're really supposed to do things because we love them - but who knows why we love to do the things we do at all - it could just be some evolutionary/biological reason. This is going off on a tangent which is in no way related to bodies/souls. Sorry.

My Last Duchess

In our discussions of the give and take between poetry and paintings in class thus far, the norm has been for poetry to do the giving and paintings to do the taking. Most often, it is an artist who interprets or draws inspiration from a selection of poetry, not the other way around. Interestingly, I think the tables might be turned if we examine Browning's "My Last Duchess." This poem is commonly understood to be an historical reference to Alfonso II, Duke of Ferrara, and his first wife Lucrezia di Cosimo de' Medici, daughter of the Grand Duke of Tuscany, who lived in the mid 16th century. According to history, Lucrezia died under suspicious circumstances after only a few years of marriage at age 17. Poison was suspected to be a possible cause. Anyway, the famous Italian painter Agnolo Bronzino painted a portrait of Lucrezia before she died -- and so naturally I have been looking at the painting to see if it could have served as the source for Browning's inspiration three hundred years later.
File:Agnolo Bronzino, ritratto di Lucrezia de' Medici.JPG
This is a copy of the image (sorry it is so large). For me at least, there is something powerful and engaging about this portrait, especially if we examine the facial expression of Lucrezia. Certainly "the depth and passion of its earnest glance" is clear. I am not sure if the Duchess is smiling, indeed, her piercing look almost suggests the opposite - deep loneliness and despair. Either way, if Browning actually did look to this portrait for inspiration, I think it must be important to interpreting his poem. If he did not, then it remains interesting to compare the real-life representation of a character forever memorialized by Browning's famous poem.

My Last Duchess

Properzia Rossi

Last class we talked a little bit with regards to Isabella; or, The Pot of Basil about how themes are incorporated throughout different art forms, particularly with poetry and painting, and how they are interpreted similarly or differently in the work. This relationship with painting and poetry seems to repeat itself throughout history, which I find very interesting. I was unable to find Ducis' painting of the work, but I was able to find a description of the painting that described Properzia Rossi showing her last work to a knight, presumably her lover, who basically looked like he didn't care about her work or wasn't impressed. Throughout the poem we see Hemans describe Rossi's work with references to nature (roses, sunshine, etc.), and then describe the lover's reaction to the work with references to death. I assume the lover was not literally killing Properzia, although I may be wrong, and that this is a metaphor to show how her lover has taken away part of her life by not caring about her work. I also think the combination of nature and death simile's is interesting, as this appeared in many of the poems in last week's class.

Porphyria's Lover & Its Underlying Meaning

As I read Porphyria's Lover, I was definitely surprised at the ending. I knew it wasn't going to be happy but I didn't expect him to strangle her and then take her body and make it seem like she was resting on his shoulder... I propped her head up as before, Only, this time my shoulder bore/Her head, which droops upon it still (lines 49-50). He continues to touch her like she was still alive...I warily oped her lids...her cheek once more/Blushed bright beneath my burning kiss (lines 44-48). It is creepy to imagine a person manipulating a dead body that way, especially since her killed her. This poem is in the collection Men and Women, which Browning dedicated to his wife which I think is interesting. But what is the meaning behind this poem? Is it a social commentary and warning for women and their behavior? Or is it a critique on both genders since the the man killed her?

Nature also plays an important role in the beginning of the poem and describing the cottage and storm. Porphyria shows her love for him by coming to his cottage in a storm. She also risks her social standing because it was considered inappropriate for her to conduct herself in this manner.

Saturday, March 27, 2010

Woman Trapped

A theme that I picked up on in the reading of both Mariana and the Lady of Shallot is this concept of women being trapped by their despair over a failed love or love gone awry. This gives a keen insight into the way men of Tennyson's time saw women and their dependence on men for fulfillment and romance. I think it also suggests something about the arrogance of men in terms of nature as well. Both poems use a lot of natural imagery and I think suggest a similar kind of dependence of nature on the power and whim of man. Considering the time of empire that Tennyson writes in and his other works (Light Brigade) this kind of imperialistic impulse makes a lot of sense.

The Duke's agency revealed in the poetic structure? - "My Last Duchess"

I think the commentary that Browning is making in this poem is very interesting. I gathered that he was critiquing a man’s absolute control that he has on his wife in society. In the poem, the Duke is so obsessed with control that he killed his first wife because he could not effectively control her.

The way in which Browning portrays the Duke’s voice made me question the agency of the poem. On the surface, it seems that the Duke is controlling the conversation and that he seems very confident in his words, but there is strong sense of artificially that appears throughout the poem. As we learn more about what really happened to the Duchess, the rhythm and structure of the poem ties into the emotion of the speaker. For example, the enjambment of the lines takes the Duke’s seemingly matter-of-fact speech and makes it appear illogical. Thus, while the Duke wants to make it appear as if he is in “control” of the conversation, his overriding obsession with control actually controls him through his guilt…?

Thursday, March 25, 2010

On Reading "The Lady of Shalott"

I don't know if it was intentional or not, but despite of (and maybe because of) the intense rhyme scheme in "The Lady of Shalott," the entire work came across more as a story than a poem. Obviously poems can tell stories; that's not what I'm getting at. What I mean to say is when reading this poem, it struck me more like a Poe work rather than a Wordsworth or Keats. Perhaps it was just the emphasis on the repetition at the end of each stanza that reminded me of instances like in Poe's "The Raven" (The whole 'nevermore' bit).

I'm not sure. For some reason, the entire thing just threw me for a loop in general. I definitely liked it, it was just... an experience, for lack of a better term.

Women and nature

In both The Lady of Shalott and Mariana I noticed Tennyson's use of nature to illustrate the condition of the central character. As Kathryn points out, the decay of the world around her reflects Mariana's passive degradation. In the third stanza, the oxen's low "without hope of changes" captures her sense of hopeless desertion.

Likewise, in The Lady of Shalott, Tennyson uses the setting to shed light on the protagonist. The entire country seems to have a sense of enchantment, from the image of the sun, the white willows, and the "stream that runneth ever. When the spell is broken, the pastoral imagery changes into stormy weather, the woods turn pale yellow, the stream strains its banks, foreshadowing the Lady's loss of control. I felt like her action had a deep sense of irrationality, since she seems to fulfill her own curse.

"Mariana"

Thinking about the theme of this week—Romance Perverted—it is easy to think about just how “messed up” so many of these relationships are—from a girl loving a pot of basil to a serial killing beauty. The theme continues in Tennyson’s poetry, especially “Mariana.” The chief characteristic of the poem that I noticed is the way the natural world reflects Mariana’s interior life. From the very first stanza, nature is described as decaying: “rusted nails”, “weeded and worn”, etc. Mariana declares repeatedly that she wishes she was “dead”—this state would mirror the natural world around her. This wish is caused by the fact that “He cometh not” which suggests that Mariana has been forsaken by a lover or that her lover has died. It seems extreme to wish for death when one loses a lover, but this, of course, fits perfectly with perverted love. It’s interesting that we don’t even know the story about Mariana’s lost love, and it makes me want to build a back story—kind of like what Liz suggested in her post regarding “La Belle Dame Sans Merci” and we discussed in class. What is it that made her lover leave or caused her lover’s death and Mariana’s decay into absolute despair?