Sunday, April 25, 2010

Chinua Achebe: Things Fall Apart

Achebe's novel Things Fall Apart takes both its title and several of its key themes from Yeats' poem The Second Coming. The novel's title comes from the line, "Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold", which as many of you have noted here and in class is a comment on the nature of empire. As we said, history shows that there comes a point when all empires, every one from the Roman Empire, to Napoleon's conquests, to the British Empire, spin out of control. The lines "the falcon cannot hear the falconer" speak to how the mother empire can lose control of her children colonies. Things Fall Apart is the story of intense native tribal drama which is impossible for an British imperialist to understand. An imperial power may impose its way of life on the culture it colonizes, but it can never fully overwhelm or erase the pre-existing societal structure and customs, a fact that ultimately contributes to the empire's downfall. One quote I remember from the novel is the title a British man had chosen to document the deep-rooted tribal struggles of the novel: "The Pacification of the Tribes of the Lower Niger". One fundamental misunderstanding all empires have is that one culture can absorb another, something that is impossible. So what kind of "rough beast" will come of this flawed imperialist mentality?

Saturday, April 24, 2010

Death Of Youth in Kipling's Epitaphs

Kipling's Epitaphs are interesting little poems. Short and sentimental, they all have a similar tone describing needless young death. I often find it difficult to cope with death, and these short poems give an insight into Kipling's personal feelings about war and death. "The Coward," is particularly striking, "I could not look on Death, which being known, / Men led me to him, blindfold and alone." Is death the coward, or is the narrator? A common theme in the epitaphs is the lack of choice, especially in, "The Beginner," where Kipling describes the death of his own son, "On the first hour of my first day / In the front trench I fell." Death comes for us all, but in these poems Kipling asks why so many young men must die for no reason.

Thursday, April 22, 2010

Kipling's Epitaph, "The Beginner"

This was my favorite of all of his epitaphs: it's just so sad. I love WWI because there was such a beautiful innocence about the world that got completely smashed apart.


The Beginner


On the first hour of my first day

In the front trench I fell.

(Children in boxes at a play

Stand up to watch it well).


My dad made me read a book last summer called The Great War and Modern Memory, which talked about the changes in literature that happened as a result of WWI. Before WWI, modern europe believed in progress and though they were moving forward. There hadn't been a major war since the Second Treaty of Paris that ended the Napoleonic Wars, when almost all of the major and minor european countries agreed upon a Balance of Power between the nations. After awhile, war became something that was glorified - people read The Iliad and imagined heroes - Achilles and Agamemnon. And all the time leading up to the war, as we've read - was filled with romanticism. People wrote poetry about knights and kings, heroes - and that which came along with them - the beautiful, innocent princesses, the lovely lady waiting for her soldier to return home, scarred but valiant. All of that was an illusion, of course - a world before poison gas, tanks, trenches, airplanes, and effective artillery.


So, once these valiant heroes marched off to war, they realized how truly horrible it was - and the type of prose and poetry that entered WWI, all flowery and nature-oriented, was transformed. After the war, disillusionment and stark prose characterized modern writing. Images of death and pointless brutality, or senseless death, were rampant. And that's where this comes into play - stories of innocence that meet with senseless, immediate death. A boy who looks over the top of the trench to see the battle - to see the artillery burst like stars in the air, to see the land transformed from a place of trees into a cratered, surrealist moonscape - for that he is killed, a child, innocent, and most of all, foolish.


And that's the thing I really see that characterizes these poems - a sense of sardonic humor, that grins at the absolute misery of reality, and thinks How could we have been so foolish?




Things Fall Apart

Taking a cue from Yeats' "The Second Coming", the poems we have read for this week all seem to deal with the theme of "things fall[ing] apart." It seems evident that we have entered the 20th century and are dealing with the time period around World War I. There is a sense of hopelessness behind these poems, whether it is Yeats ("And what rough beast, its hour come round at last, / Slouches towards Bethlehem to be born?") or Hardy ("That night your great guns, unawares, / Shook all our coffins as we lay...") or Kipling ("I have slain none except my Mother. She / (Blessing her slayer) died of grief for me"), they all speak of war and its negative effects, most prominently, death. The worlds in these poems are bleak and falling apart. They all offer social commentary--mostly anti-war (even though they would not agree on the rightness or wrongness of imperialism, since Kipling was one of imperialism's biggest fans)--and in this way they connect with most of the authors we have read throughout the course. They are all writing with greater meaning and a desire to effect thought/change. In these more modern poems, however, I detect a greater bleakness than existed in earlier writings. Perhaps, they reflect the (what I believe is) more modern idea of nihilism--things fall apart, and that's all there is to life.

Tommy and Imperialism

The poem Tommy presents a kind of interesting situation. Kipling seems to me to be yearning for a time when the soldier was a romanticized hero and war still had a romantic notion. At the same time he recognizes the unpopularity of war in the time that he writes and hence the unpopularity of soldiers. Perhaps because of his imperialist leanings, Kipling rushes to the aid of the soldier by taking on his voice. The didactic message of the poem seems to warn the British that they need to do right by their soldiers and honor them because they realize the disrespect they get even in the light of their perilous sacrifice. Kipling himself was a proponent of extreme right wing politics and this poem seems to push in a very real way those feelings of the need to support the troops at all times. Kipling and his voice in the poem seem to favor cowboy diplomacy. I actually really like this poem and appreciate its message. I sent it to a fraternity brother of mine at West Point. With that said, it speaks to the precise reason that Kipling historical legacy has been very fluid. Because of the nature of a lot of his work it is impossible to separate his politics from his art. Particularly because his politics supported a morally questionable practice (imperialism) it makes his work hard to read in a vacuum, even more so than other artists.

Wednesday, April 21, 2010

The Bridegroom

Kipling's epitaph "The Bridegroom" stood out to me due to its thematic connection to some of the previous poems we have read this semester like "Alonzo the Brave" and "Lenora." Whereas we have seen authors describe marriage as a type of death or leading to the grave, in this epitaph Kipling portrays Death itself as a lover that steals the bridegroom from his bride. I especially liked how the poem portrays the narrator apologizing for his unfaithfulness, and asking her to not call him false. He is almost trying to justify to her the reason why he abandoned her with rational, structured arguments about the situation, talking about how Death had a legitimate claim to him before his true bride showed up. This poem offers a powerful image of death as the "ancient bride" who has legitimate claim to the groom- even to steal him from the arms of his beloved.

The last stanza from this poem made me shiver. Reading it, I felt like the poet was saying that the bridegroom expected to endure eternity with his new bride- death.

Kipling's Personae

It's almost hard to write on Kipling beyond pointing out the obvious that these poems or epitaphs are all eloquent, eerily beautiful anti-war propaganda. However, after going through them all a second time, one thing stuck out to me.

Most of the poetry we've read so far reference death/posthumous topics at least some if not frequently. For instance, Keats writes about his brother's death, his reaction to his brother's death, and even his apparent death to come. Kipling is not different in terms of topic, but he is in terms of perspective. Essentially all of these epitaphs come from the persona of one who is recently deceased. There is no lamenting of the deceased, per se; rather, it is the deceased lamenting their mistakes, misfortunes, and loved ones left behind. They remind me a lot of Emily Dickinson in this regard, at least in terms of the differing personae, though she wasn't quite as 'regretful' in hers, nor nearly as motivated to create propaganda.

A side note: It is also interesting is that these are called epitaphs. Generally, when I think of epitaphs, I think of a loved one writing about one who is deceased. For instance, seeing "beloved father and husband" on a grave. It's an interesting twist Kipling employs that I find very effective.

Apocalyptic Poetry: Yeats and Hardy

Its interesting to compare the poetry of both Yeats and Hardy during the period before and during World War I. Both poets use the Biblical reference to the return of Christ and the end of the world in their poems, but the manner in which they do so is quite different.
In Yeat's "The Second Coming" he evokes a supernatural element to the idea of the second coming (as Sarah mentioned in her earlier post). This works on the reader to emphasis that the events leading up to this war are something that can't hardly be fathomed, and bare a strong tone of horror.
In comparison, Hardy also makes strong use of the apocalyptic imagery. he describes the noise of gunfire and compares this to "Judgement Day." However, his poem has a much more realistic tone than Yeat's - focused on the details and common events that actually took place. However, this realism evokes a similar tone of horror and dread simply in the fact that the situations are actually happening.
I think the religious allusions in both of these poems work to emphasis the disillusionment of religion felt by the witnesses of the war. As a question of agency, this shows their hopelessness towards human nature after the war, and they feel as if they can't stop the coming horrors from occuring...

Landscape and Alienation

The profound sense of alienation evoked in Yeats' "The Second Coming" seems odd in connection with the other works we've been reading. On the one hand, the desolate landscape described in
Hardly are those words out
When a vast image out of Spiritus Mundi
Troubles my sight: a waste of desert sand;
A shape with lion body and the head of a man,
A gaze blank and pitiless as the sun,
Is moving its slow thighs, while all about it
Wind shadows of the indignant desert birds.
The darkness drops again but now I know
seems to invoke a sort of supernatural in "a waste of desert sand," and "a gaze blank and pitiless as the sun." This supernatural is not the same as the sort seen in The Castle of Otranto and other works, which focus on the supernatural in the personal, the individual. Even in earlier Yeats' poems, the supernatural is placed in the hands of the individual. I wander what it means that the supernatural has entered into the landscape instead of the individual. With the landscape as the conduit for the supernatural, there seems to be no space left for the individual.

Tuesday, April 20, 2010

Old Man Traveling & The Stolen Child

As I read The Stolen Child, I couldn't help but think about Old Man Traveling and the similarities between the two of them. Nature is personified in both of them and they each have a refrain that changes in the last stanza.
Come away, O human child!
To to waters and the wild
With a faery, hand in hand,
For to world's more full of weeping than you can understand
For be comes, the human child, 50
To the waters and the wild
With a faery, hand in hand,
From a world more full of weeping than you can understand.
After reading about Yeats, I know he was fascinated with Irish folklore and this poem shows it with the emphasis on the faery leading the child away from home. I think it is interesting that the title suggests that the child was actually stolen, which comes across as more serious and longlasting. Also, he wrote this poem in 1889 which is the year he met Maud Gonne and fell in love with her. In such a happy situation, why does he insist that the world is full of weeping? The whole poem is dreary and references tears and unquiet dreams (lines 34 and 36) but it doesn't make sense at this time of his life.

Monday, April 19, 2010

Yeats and Materialism

As I was reading the biographical information regarding Yeats, he seems to be soundly against materialism, but "The Circus Animal's Desertion," one of his later poems, seems to question both his success as an author as well as his stance against materialism. The metaphor of circus animals as literary works lends a highly commercial feel to Yeats' career. Circus animals, or freaks, are spectacles that people pay money to see; they are entertainment. If Yeats' literature is a circus animal, is it not just another material entertainment? And how does this relate to his anti-materialistic views? Perhaps because this is a reflection on his career he realizes the contradiction of his work and his views? The relationship becomes even more complex when he analyzes the merit of his work, finding that the true beauty of each poem is in the dream it inspires, which is abstract and, thus, immaterial. Yet Yeats claims that he has ignored the foundation of his work, the "foul rag-and-bone shop of the heart," which could be the material, or tangible, aspects of his work (ln. 40). It seems to me that this poem is full of contradictions: his anti-materialist attitude is contradicted by the notion of circus animals, which is then contradicted by the claim that Yeats is selling dreams. Maybe this reflects Yeats' own conflict, or perhaps there is a relationship I cannot see. Does anyone else have thoughts?

The Rag-and-Bone Shop of the Heart

I enjoyed reading the compilation of Yeats poem, and found in them a reoccurring theme of wishing for the past, but instead finding oneself in the weary present attempting to start over at life, at love, of trying to regain youth and innocence.
I found "The Circus Animals' Desertion" most consistent with what we have discussed this semester. To begin with, there is a "broken man" at the start of the poem, which immediately alerts us to the fact that something is unnatural, there must be something wrong if he is "broken." Secondly, the Circus is often associated with "freaks of nature," or creatures that don't fit into what we see as our reality. The people/animals/things in a circus are by nature, strange.

My circus animals were all on show,
Those stilted boys, that burnished chariot,
Lion and woman and the Lord knows what.


I find it interesting that he groups women in the category of the strange and unknowable, even to the Lord who is supposed to know everything. These are creatures beyond the normal realm of reason. Yeats then goes off into a sort of dreamy, enchanted world that is a little bizarre.
The speaker's brokenness is accompanied by the image of "The Countess Cathleen" wants to give away her soul, (which is not natural), and this brings up the comparison between the body and the soul.
Then there is the "Fool" and the "Blind Man," who can both be considered outsiders who never quite fit in. The reference to Cuchulain (aka the "Irish Achilles") brings in his irrational strength that is otherworldly and superhuman if he is able to fight the "ungovernable sea." However, all heroes have a week spot. The speaker was enchanted by a dream, not reality, and when in the last stanza he finds himself back in the harshness of the real world full of broken objects.

At the end, he mourns all the work he had done in the past, the love he had built up, saying that his ladder is now gone, and his weary tone suggests he doesn't really feel up to creating a new ladder. The speaker says "I must lie down where all the ladders start/In the foul rag-and-bone shop of the heart," which is to say that love's imperfection causes broken-heartedness. He cannot even stand up and climb, he is reduced to a supine position. This all refers back to the absurdness and irrationality we have seen so far.

Saturday, April 17, 2010

Empire in Holmes

As we discussed in class I think that there are obvious attacks of class and empire in Sherlock Holmes. For me one of the most interesting pieces of the book was when the KKK becomes a part of the action. That entire story is very gothic because of the disappearance of the ship and at the beginning of it the semblance of haunting that is created by the letters inscribed with KKK. It seems like the spoils of imperialism and empire are coming back to haunt the British. This is because the letter is addressed from India as well as it directly references American slavery which is a part of the British colonial legacy. While Holmes identifies the murderers they are not caught which to me suggests that even though unjust wrongs have been done to British people, those small injustices do not absolve them from the sin of empire. The lack of clear resolution says that there can be no justice for the British who have been operating and profiting from unjust rule for so long. It's a very dark reading but I think pretty appropriate.

Thursday, April 15, 2010

Holmes' take on drug usage

Today in class we discussed the general themes that Sherlock Holmes seems to address. We decided that the book advocates middle class education and training, comments on the corruption of the upper class, stresses that all of the social entanglements caused by upper class corruption and problems with the middle class must be fixed, claims the superiority of natural law over positive law, and says that the middle class needs to separate themselves from drugs, immorality, and deception. In seems like most of us are in agreement about these general ideas, but I am still struggling with interpreting Doyle's take on drug use. In the stories, Holmes is presented as sort of separate from the middle class, but not quite part of the corrupted upper class either. He acts as a role model that Watson and the rest of the middle class should follow. Holmes can recognize the "types" (or stereotypes) that everyone around him sees, yet he is not confined by them - he recognizes individuals as well. In every way he acts as the role model for Britain's middle-class. Where, then, does his drug use fit in? If he is actually a role model, and engages in opium and cocaine use, then is Doyle advocating the use of drugs? The rest of the book makes clear that Doyle believes the rampant drug use within his country to be a serious problem, but I think that Holmes' use compromises that message.

In addition, someone's response to my question about this today was that Holmes recognizes natural law as superior to positive law. But positive law in Britain at the time allowed opium use, whereas natural law clearly recognizes drugs as bad. By using drugs, Holmes appears to support positive law in place of natural law. Anyway, I'm still having trouble processing this so if anyone could clarify it would be a big help.

Sorolla, Clotilde

Induction vs Deduction

One theme I've found throughout the Holmes stories is the critique on reasoning that Doyle employs. At this time in history, most trains of thought were based around an "inductive" style of reasoning - that is, "clues" or "evidence" was sorted into categories, and based on the category a response was chosen. Even Watson, a doctor, was prone to this. Just like other doctors at the time, Watson would see clues for a case much like he would symptoms in an illness. Based on what illness the symptoms seemed to indicate, he had a regimented treatment for that illness.

Holmes takes another approach. While at first seeming similar in that both characters use evidence to support their conclusions, Holmes' utilization of deduction, while potentially open-ended and inconclusive, proves to be a much more valid method in many cases. He takes the clues for what they are and pieces them together, without a regard for what convention may suggest the clues indicate.

I feel that Watson would say, "If it looks like a duck, walks like a duck, and quacks like a duck, then it's a duck and we should feed it bread." However I see Holmes as saying something more like, "If it looks like a duck, walks like a duck, and quacks like a duck, then we've only proven it to be like a duck."

As a side note, the deductive style of reasoning is more common in medicine today, I think. Rather than having one approach to an illness, doctors more and more often develop individualized plans of treatment. While they can't defenestrate convention's suggestions as easily as Holmes seemed to, it is a marked change.

Stranger than Fiction

In the Sherlock Holmes stories, Holmes remarks several times that real life is often weirder than the mind can imagine: "we must go to life itself, which is always far more daring than any efforts of the imagination" (51). Holmes' insistence on the strangeness of everyday life and his preference for the smaller cases that present idiosyncratic details versus the large/high-profile cases that all seem the same, reflect Doyle's awareness of the weirdness of his society. We have discussed the strangeness of British society--especially at the beginning of the semester (ridiculous corsets, wigs, etc.)--and how Britons focused on the weirdness of other societies (African and American) rather than recognizing their own eccentricities. Doyle, however, points out the unusual facets of British society through normalizing weird--calling out life in general to be weird. Through these stories of odd crimes, odd human behavior, Doyle easily entertains his readers by allowing them to join in his observation of the odd, and yet he also shows them just how odd normal life can be. The question is, did they know that by going "How strange!" about the events and characters in the stories they were actually going "How strange!" about their society and possibly themselves?

Wednesday, April 14, 2010

Seeing vs. Observing

In class on Tuesday we ended talking about the difference between seeing and observing. Watson sees everything, but he overlooks the important details.
In "The Red-Handed League," Watson tries to analyze Mr. Jabez Wilson "after the fashion of my companion to read hte indications which might be presented by his dress or appearance."
However, he only notices his clothing and concludes that "there was nothing remarkable about the man save his blazing red head, and the expression of extreme chagrin and discontent upon his features."
In a matter of mere minutes though, Holmes has figured out that this man has "done manual labor, that he takes snuff, that he is a Freemason, that he has been in China, and that he has done a considerable amount of writing lately."
Watson sees what is on the exterior, but usually does not get past the colors and shapes of the clothing, which are details that could be important, but are sometimes irrelevant.
According to dictionary.com, to observe is: to see, watch, perceive, or notice and to regard with attention, esp. so as to see or learn something.
In each of the cases, it is meticulous observation that solves the crime.
So the difference between seeing and observing? Seeing is looking on the surface that the coat is red, but observing is noticing that the sleeves are too short, and too tight around the shoulders, indicating that the wearer is strapped for cash or has little time/does not care to shop. (Ok, so maybe not such a great example but I'm not Sherlock Holmes.)

The Elementary Case of "A Case of Identity"

"A Case of Identity," seems a rather perverse tale upon review. Miss Sutherland, a victim of deceit by her own step-father, who engages in a romantic relationship with her using a disguise. While Holmes reasons that his motives were financial in nature, I feel that Mr. James Windinbank, being 15 years younger than his wife, had more sexual desires with Miss Sutherland, but couldn't follow through with his plans when she began asking too many questions. It seems rather strange that a young girl wouldn't recognize her own stepfather, and that she would agree to marry Hosmer Angel without knowing hardly anything about him; however, love can be a powerful force often blinding a person to observation. This is precisely why Holmes chooses not to reveal his conclusion to her.

Holme's keen sense of observation, seen in his description of Miss Sutherland's sleeve, and again in the characteristics of the type-writer, is a pervasive theme throughout this and the other the stories in the collection. However, this story differs from some of the others in its simplicity. Holmes finds the case, "elementary," and even I came to a similar conclusion after reading Miss Sutherland's description of the case and the title of the story. This story was most likely written for an experienced Sherlock Holmes audience to be able to figure out before the end, which fits in with our discussion the other day about the use of periodicals in delivering the stories to the masses.

Tuesday, April 13, 2010

Holmes and Mr. Utterson

There is an obvious connection between "Sherlock Holmes" and "Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde" in the fact that they are both short stories that unravel a mystery. This parallel places Holmes and Mr. Utterson in comparable positions as the detective figure in each work, yet their methods of discovery and theorizing are strikingly different. Mr. Utterson tries to maintain a rational viewpoint by assuming that Mr. Hyde is a manipulative criminal, and he relies strictly on the documented facts as we discussed last week. Despite his attempt to stick to evidence, his imagination constantly wanders but without the efficiency that arises from Holmes' thoughts. Holmes does not focus solely on the evidence; instead, he acknowledges that evidence can point in the wrong direction or be misinterpreted. This is a concept that Mr. Utterson was unable to grasp, leaving him without the full scope of information necessary to solve the mystery of Dr. Jekyll. I think the difference between Holmes and Mr. Utterson has an interesting tie in to our discussion of observation vs. seeing in class. Although Mr. Utterson sees everything just like Watson, he is unable to observe everything like Holmes. Perhaps then, observation is not only derived from visual clues but from cognitive assumptions as well? Holmes does notice the tiny details, but it is his deductions that truly separate him from Watson or Mr. Utterson.